Differences Between Dedicated and Shared Load Balancers

Updated on 2024-04-19 GMT+08:00

View PDF

Each type of load balancer has their advantages.

Feature Comparison

Dedicated load balancers provide more powerful forwarding performance, while shared load balancers are less expensive. You can select the appropriate load balancer based on your application needs. The following tables compare the features supported by the two types of load balancers. (√ indicates that an item is supported, and x indicates that an item is not supported.)

**Table 1** Performance
Item	Dedicated Load Balancers	Shared Load Balancers
Deployment mode	Their performance is not affected by other load balancers. You can select different specifications based on your requirements.	Shared load balancers are deployed in clusters, and all the load balancers share underlying resources, so that the performance of a load balancer is affected by other load balancers.
Concurrent connections	A dedicated load balancer in an AZ can establish up to 20 million concurrent connections. If you deploy a dedicated load balancer in two AZs, the number of concurrent connections will be doubled. For example, if you deploy a dedicated load balancer in two AZs, it can handle up to 40 million concurrent connections. NOTE: If requests are from the Internet, the load balancer in each AZ you select routes the requests based on source IP addresses. If you deploy a load balancer in two AZs, the requests the load balancers can handle will be doubled. For requests from a private network: If clients are in the AZ you selected when you created the load balancer, requests are distributed by the load balancer in this AZ. If the load balancer is unavailable, requests are distributed by the load balancer in another AZ you select. If the load balancer is available but the connections that the load balancer needs to handle exceed the amount defined in the specifications, service may be interrupted. To address this issue, you need upgrade specifications. You can monitor traffic usage on private network by AZ. If clients are in an AZ that is not selected when you create the load balancer, requests are distributed by the load balancer in each AZ you select based on source IP addresses. If clients are in a VPC that is different from where the load balancer works, the load balancer in the AZ where the original VPC subnet resides routes the requests. If the load balancer in this AZ is unavailable, requests are distributed by the load balancer in another AZ.	-

**Table 2** Supported protocols
Protocol	Description	Dedicated Load Balancers	Shared Load Balancers
QUIC	If you use UDP as the frontend protocol, you can select QUIC as the backend protocol, and select the connection ID algorithm to route requests with the same connection ID to the same backend server. QUIC has the advantages of low latency, high reliability, and no head-of-line blocking (HOL blocking), and is very suitable for the mobile Internet. No new connections need to be established when you switch between a Wi-Fi network and a mobile network.	√	x
HTTP/2	Hypertext Transfer Protocol 2.0 (HTTP/2) is a new version of the HTTP protocol. HTTP/2 is compatible with HTTP/1.X and provides improved performance and security. Only HTTPS listeners support this feature.	√	√
TCP/UDP (Layer 4)	After receiving TCP or UDP requests from the clients, the load balancer directly routes the requests to backend servers. Load balancing at Layer 4 features high routing efficiency.	√	√
HTTP/HTTPS (Layer 7)	After receiving a request, the listener needs to identify the request and forward data based on the fields in the HTTP/HTTPS packet header. Though the routing efficiency is lower than that at Layer 4, load balancing at Layer 7 provides some advanced features such as encrypted transmission and cookie-based sticky sessions.	√	√
WebSocket	WebSocket is a new HTML5 protocol that provides full-duplex communication between the browser and the server. WebSocket saves server resources and bandwidth, and enables real-time communication.	√	√

**Table 3** Supported backend types
Backend Server Type	Description	Dedicated Load Balancers	Shared Load Balancers
IP as backend servers	You can add servers in a VPC connected using a VPC peering connection, in a VPC connected through a cloud connection, or in an on-premises data center at the other end of a Direct Connect or VPN connection, by using the server IP addresses. In this way, incoming traffic can be flexibly distributed to cloud servers and on-premises servers for hybrid load balancing.	√	x
ECS	You can use load balancers to distribute incoming traffic across ECSs.	√	√

**Table 4** Advanced forwarding (HTTP/HTTPS listeners)
Component	Condition	Description	Dedicated Load Balancers	Shared Load Balancers
Forwarding rule	Domain name	Load balancers can route requests based on domain names. The domain name in the request must exactly match that in the forwarding policy.	√	√
	URL	Load balancers can route requests based on URLs. There are three URL matching rules: exact match, prefix match, and regular expression match.	√	√
	HTTP request method	You can route requests based on any HTTP method. The options include GET, POST, PUT, DELETE, PATCH, HEAD and OPTIONS.	√	x
	HTTP header	You can route requests based on the value of any HTTP header. An HTTP header consists of a key and one or more values. You need to configure the key and values separately.	√	x
	Query string	You can route requests based on the query string.	√	x
	CIDR block (source IP addresses)	You can route requests based on source IP addresses from where the requests originate.	√	x
Action	Forward to a backend server group	Requests are forwarded to the specified backend server group for processing.	√	√
	Redirect to another listener	Requests are redirected to another listener, which then routes the requests to its associated backend server group.	√	x
	Redirect to another URL	Requests are redirected to the configured URL. When clients access website A, the load balancer returns 302 or any other 3xx status code and automatically redirects the clients to website B. You can custom the redirection URL that will be returned to the clients.	√	x
	Return a specific response body	Load balancers return a fixed response to the clients. You can custom the status code and response body that load balancers directly return to the clients without the need to route the requests to backend servers.	√	x

**Table 5** Advanced features
Feature	Description	Dedicated Load Balancers	Shared Load Balancers
Multiple specifications	Load balancers allow you to select appropriate specifications based on your requirements.	√	x
HTTPS support	Load balancers can receive HTTPS requests from clients and route them to an HTTPS backend server group.	√	x
IPv6 addresses	Load balancers can route requests from IPv6 clients. You can change the IPv6 address bound to a load balancer and unbind the IPv6 address from the load balancer.	√	x
Changing the private IPv4 address bound to the load balancer	You can change the private IPv4 address bound to a load balancer.	√	x
Slow start	You can enable slow start for HTTP or HTTPS listeners. After you enable it, the load balancer linearly increases the proportion of requests to send to backend servers in this mode. Slow start gives applications time to warm up and respond to requests with optimal performance.	√	x
Mutual authentication	In this case, you need to deploy both the server certificate and client certificate. Mutual authentication is supported only by HTTPS listeners.	√	√
Custom timeout durations	You can configure and modify timeout durations (idle timeout, request timeout, and response timeout) for your listeners to meet varied demands. For example, if the size of a request from an HTTP or HTTPS client is large, you can increase the request timeout duration to ensure that the request can be successfully routed. Dedicated load balancers: You can change the timeout durations of TCP, UDP, HTTP, and HTTPS listeners. Shared load balancers: You can only change the timeout durations of TCP, HTTP, and HTTPS listeners, but cannot change the timeout durations of UDP listeners.	√	√
Security policies	When you add HTTPS listeners, you can select appropriate security policies to improve service security. A security policy is a combination of TLS protocols and cipher suites.	√	√
Passing the listener's port number to backend servers	The listener's port number is stored in the X-Forwarded-Port header and passed to backend servers.	√	√
Passing the client's port number to backend servers	The client's port number is stored in the X-Forwarded-For-Port header and passed to backend servers.	√	√
Rewriting X-Forwarded-Host	If you disable this option, the load balancer passes the X-Forwarded-Host field to backend servers. If you enable this option, the load balancer rewrites the X-Forwarded-Host field based on the Host field in the request header sent from the client and sends the rewritten X-Forwarded-Host field to backend servers.	√	√

**Table 6** Other features
Feature	Description	Dedicated Load Balancers	Shared Load Balancers
Customized cross-AZ deployment	You can create a load balancer in multiple AZs. Each AZ selects an optimal path to process requests. In addition, the AZs back up each other, improving service processing efficiency and reliability. If you deploy a load balancer in multiple AZs, its performance such as the number of new connections and the number of concurrent connections will multiply. For example, if you deploy a dedicated load balancer in two AZs, it can handle up to 40 million concurrent connections. NOTE: If requests are from the Internet, the load balancer in each AZ you select routes the requests based on source IP addresses. If you deploy a load balancer in two AZs, the requests the load balancers can handle will be doubled. For requests from a private network: If clients are in the AZ you selected when you created the load balancer, requests are distributed by the load balancer in this AZ. If the load balancer is unavailable, requests are distributed by the load balancer in another AZ you select. If the load balancer is available but the connections that the load balancer needs to handle exceed the amount defined in the specifications, service may be interrupted. To address this issue, you need upgrade specifications. You can monitor traffic usage on private network by AZ. If clients are in an AZ that is not selected when you create the load balancer, requests are distributed by the load balancer in each AZ you select based on source IP addresses. If clients are in a VPC that is different from where the load balancer works, the load balancer in the AZ where the original VPC subnet resides routes the requests. If the load balancer in this AZ is unavailable, requests are distributed by the load balancer in another AZ.	√	x
Connection ID	Load balancers can use the connection ID algorithm to route requests. The connection ID in the packet is calculated using the consistent hash algorithm to obtain a specific value, and backend servers are numbered. The generated value determines to which backend server the requests are routed.	√	x
Load balancing algorithms	Load balancers support weighted round robin, weighted least connections, and source IP hash.	√	√
Load balancing over public and private networks	Each load balancer on a public network has a public IP address bound to it and routes requests from clients to backend servers over the Internet. Load balancers on a private network work within a VPC and route requests from clients to backend servers in the same VPC.	√	√
Modifying the bandwidth	You can modify the bandwidth used by the EIP bound to the load balancer as required.	√	√
Binding/Unbinding an IP address	You can bind an IP address to a load balancer or unbind the IP address from a load balancer based on service requirements.	√	√
Sticky session	If you enable sticky sessions, requests from the same client will be routed to the same backend server during the session.	√	√
Access control	You can add IP addresses to a whitelist or blacklist to control access to a listener. A whitelist allows specified IP addresses to access the listener. A blacklist denies access from specified IP addresses.	√	√
Health check	Load balancers periodically send requests to backend servers to check whether they can process requests.	√	√
Certificate management	You can create two types of certificates: server certificate and CA certificate. If you need an HTTPS listener, you need to bind a server certificate to it. To enable mutual authentication, you also need to bind a CA certificate to the listener. You can also replace a certificate that is already used by a load balancer.	√	√
Tagging	If you have a large number of cloud resources, you can assign different tags to the resources to quickly identify them and use these tags to easily manage your resources.	√	√
Monitoring	You can use Cloud Eye to monitor load balancers and associated resources and view metrics on the management console.	√	√
Log auditing	You can use Cloud Trace Service (CTS) to record operations on load balancers and associated resources for query, auditing, and backtracking.	√	√